# Data validation report

National accounts (MoSPI), the Union Budget's GDP assumption and published forecasts. Every allowed exception lists its reason.

**Result: PASSED** (12869 checks, 0 failures)

## ✅ Every published row is understood
10272 checks, 0 failures.

- Allowed: nas/2011-12/Current/Annually/ind19: row with year '1999' left out (not a fiscal year): Gross National Disposable Income First Advance Estimates 36204793. Reason: MoSPI's API returns one Gross National Disposable Income row (First Advance Estimate, ₹3,62,04,793 crore) labelled with the year '1999'. No fiscal year is given, so the row is left out. The value matches no other GNDI figure in the series and does not affect GDP or growth.
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, agriculture, crops: published twice with different real growth (0.1 and 0.2); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, agriculture, forestry_and_logging: published twice with different real growth (0.2 and 0.3); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, agriculture: published twice with different real growth (1.4 and 1.5); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, construction: published twice with different real growth (0.3 and 0.5); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, construction: published twice with different real growth (0.3 and 0.6); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, financial: published twice with different real growth (10.3 and 9.6); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing, food_products_beverages_and_tobacco: published twice with different real growth (-6.3 and -7.7); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing, machinery_and_equipment: published twice with different real growth (2.9 and 3); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing, machinery_and_equipment: published twice with different real growth (2.9 and 3.3); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing, metal_products: published twice with different real growth (1.5 and 1.7); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing, metal_products: published twice with different real growth (1.5 and 3.8); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing, other_manufactured_goods: published twice with different real growth (8.7 and 9.5); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing, other_manufactured_goods: published twice with different real growth (8.7 and 9.9); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing, textiles_apparel_and_leather_products: published twice with different real growth (15.7 and 19.6); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing, textiles_apparel_and_leather_products: published twice with different real growth (15.7 and 19.7); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing: published twice with different real growth (5.4 and 5.8); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing: published twice with different real growth (5.4 and 6); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, mining: published twice with different real growth (-0.5 and 0.6); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, other_services: published twice with different real growth (6.2 and 6.3); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, public_admin: published twice with different real growth (1.6 and 2); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, total: published twice with different nominal growth (13.5 and 13.6); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, trade_hotels, hotels__restaurants: published twice with different real growth (3.2 and 3.3); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, trade_hotels, trade__repair_services: published twice with different real growth (11.8 and 11.9); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, trade_hotels: published twice with different real growth (10.9 and 11); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, transport_comm, air_transport: published twice with different real growth (-4.7 and -7); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, transport_comm, railways: published twice with different real growth (12.7 and 12.8); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, transport_comm, railways: published twice with different real growth (12.7 and 13.1); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, transport_comm, services_incidental_to_transport: published twice with different real growth (4.4 and 4.5); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, transport_comm, storage: published twice with different real growth (11.7 and 11.8); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, transport_comm, storage: published twice with different real growth (11.7 and 11.9); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, transport_comm, water_transport: published twice with different real growth (2 and 2.1); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, utilities: published twice with different real growth (2.5 and 2.6); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2012-13, gva_growth, ADD, utilities: published twice with different real growth (2.5 and 2.8); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, agriculture, crops: published twice with different real growth (4.2 and 5.3); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, agriculture, crops: published twice with different real growth (4.2 and 5.4); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, agriculture, fishing_and_aquaculture: published twice with different real growth (7.1 and 7.6); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, agriculture, forestry_and_logging: published twice with different real growth (-1.5 and 5.8); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, agriculture, forestry_and_logging: published twice with different real growth (-1.5 and 5.9); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, agriculture, livestock: published twice with different real growth (5.5 and 5.6); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, agriculture: published twice with different real growth (4.2 and 5.5); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, construction: published twice with different real growth (2.6 and 3); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, construction: published twice with different real growth (2.6 and 4.6); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, financial: published twice with different real growth (4.8 and 9); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, financial: published twice with different real growth (4.8 and 9.2); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing, food_products_beverages_and_tobacco: published twice with different real growth (-0.1 and -0.2); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing, food_products_beverages_and_tobacco: published twice with different real growth (-0.1 and -0.6); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing, machinery_and_equipment: published twice with different real growth (-5.9 and -6.2); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing, machinery_and_equipment: published twice with different real growth (-5.9 and -8.2); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing, metal_products: published twice with different real growth (16.2 and 16.3); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing, metal_products: published twice with different real growth (16.2 and 26.2); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing, other_manufactured_goods: published twice with different real growth (1.9 and 2.8); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing, other_manufactured_goods: published twice with different real growth (1.9 and 3.1); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing, textiles_apparel_and_leather_products: published twice with different real growth (21.9 and 22.4); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing, textiles_apparel_and_leather_products: published twice with different real growth (21.9 and 23.6); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing: published twice with different real growth (4.9 and 5); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, manufacturing: published twice with different real growth (4.9 and 5.6); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, mining: published twice with different real growth (0.1 and 3); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, mining: published twice with different real growth (0.1 and 3.1); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, other_services: published twice with different real growth (5.6 and 5.7); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, public_admin: published twice with different real growth (1.7 and 3.2); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, real_estate: published twice with different real growth (11.8 and 12.1); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, real_estate: published twice with different real growth (11.8 and 12.5); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, total: published twice with different nominal growth (12.6 and 12.7); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, total: published twice with different real growth (6 and 6.2); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, total: published twice with different real growth (6 and 6.3); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, trade_hotels, hotels__restaurants: published twice with different real growth (-0.4 and 0); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, trade_hotels, hotels__restaurants: published twice with different real growth (-0.4 and 2.4); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, trade_hotels, trade__repair_services: published twice with different real growth (5.9 and 6.4); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, trade_hotels, trade__repair_services: published twice with different real growth (5.9 and 7.7); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, trade_hotels: published twice with different real growth (5.3 and 5.8); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, trade_hotels: published twice with different real growth (5.3 and 7.2); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, transport_comm, communication__services_related_to_broadcasting: published twice with different real growth (15.9 and 16); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, transport_comm, communication__services_related_to_broadcasting: published twice with different real growth (15.9 and 18); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, transport_comm, railways: published twice with different real growth (6 and 6.5); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, transport_comm, road_transport: published twice with different real growth (6.2 and 6.4); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, transport_comm, services_incidental_to_transport: published twice with different real growth (5 and 5.5); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, transport_comm, storage: published twice with different real growth (-7.9 and -8.8); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, transport_comm, storage: published twice with different real growth (-7.9 and -9); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, transport_comm, water_transport: published twice with different real growth (4.1 and 4.2); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, transport_comm: published twice with different real growth (8.3 and 8.4); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, transport_comm: published twice with different real growth (8.3 and 8.7); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, utilities: published twice with different real growth (4 and 4.1); neither is used
- Left out: 2011-12 series, 2013-14, gva_growth, ADD, utilities: published twice with different real growth (4 and 4.7); neither is used

## ✅ Accounting identities hold in every estimate
1959 checks, 0 failures.

- Checks run: 8 industries = total GVA (222); GDP = GVA + net taxes on products (414); GNDI = GNI + net current transfers from abroad (99); GNI = GDP + net primary income from abroad (198); NDP = GDP − depreciation (198); cfc by sector = total (37); finer industries = total GVA (where groups are not published) (192); gfcf by sector = total (74); industry group = its parts (18); net taxes = taxes − subsidies (74); saving by sector = total (37); sub-industries = industry (396)
- Allowed (8 figures, e.g. 2011-12 series, 2014-15, AE1, current prices: GDP = GVA + net taxes on products — printed 12,653,762, parts give 13,000,302 (-346,540)). Reason: In MoSPI's API, net taxes on products for the First Advance and Provisional Estimates of 2014-15 and 2015-16 do not equal GDP minus GVA from the same release. GDP and GVA are the published headline figures (the February 2015 release put 2014-15 real GVA at ₹98.58 lakh crore, as here), so they are shown; net taxes for these four releases are not used.
- Allowed (320 figures, e.g. 2011-12-back series, 1950-51, BACK, current prices: finer industries = total GVA (where groups are not published) — printed 9,809, parts give 10,280 (-471)). Reason: MoSPI's back series links each industry's older figures to the 2011-12 base separately, so before 2004-05 the industries do not add up exactly to total GVA (about 5% apart in 1950-51, 0.3% in 2000-01; exact from 2004-05, where the back series was recompiled in full). Industry shares on the site for these years are shares of the sum of industries.

## ✅ Published GDP growth rates follow from published GDP levels
134 checks, 0 failures.

- Which estimate of the previous year each stage's growth is measured against: ADD vs ADD (1); ADD vs RE3 (1); AE1 vs PE (13); AE1 vs RE1 (3); AE2 vs RE1 (12); AE2 vs RE2 (1); AE2 vs RE3 (1); FINAL vs FINAL (2); FINAL vs RE2 (1); PE vs PE (2); PE vs RE1 (11); PE vs RE2 (2); PE vs RE3 (1); RE1 vs FINAL (3); RE1 vs RE2 (6); RE1 vs RE3 (6); RE2 vs ADD (2); RE2 vs RE2 (1); RE2 vs RE3 (9); RE3 vs ADD (1); RE3 vs RE2 (4); RE3 vs RE3 (5)
- 46 published rates are within 1.5 points of the levels but not exact. Each was measured against an estimate of the previous year that MoSPI's API no longer keeps (it keeps one figure per year and stage, after later revisions). The site shows growth rates as MoSPI announced them. Listed for review:
- 2011-12 series, 2012-13 RE3: published real growth 5.4%, levels give RE2 5.48%, ADD 5.48%
- 2011-12 series, 2012-13 RE3: published nominal growth 13.8%, levels give RE2 13.86%, ADD 13.85%
- 2011-12 series, 2012-13 ADD: published real growth 5.4%, levels give RE2 5.46%, ADD 5.46%
- 2011-12 series, 2013-14 ADD: published real growth 6.3%, levels give RE2 6.23%, RE3 6.36%, ADD 6.39%
- 2011-12 series, 2014-15 AE1: published real growth 7.4%, levels give RE2 8.31%, RE3 8.55%, ADD 8.73%
- 2011-12 series, 2014-15 AE1: published nominal growth 11.5%, levels give RE2 12.25%, RE3 12.61%, ADD 12.64%
- 2011-12 series, 2014-15 PE: published real growth 7.3%, levels give RE2 8.18%, RE3 8.41%, ADD 8.60%
- 2011-12 series, 2014-15 PE: published nominal growth 10.5%, levels give RE2 11.25%, RE3 11.61%, ADD 11.64%
- 2011-12 series, 2014-15 RE2: published real growth 7.1%, levels give RE2 6.94%, RE3 7.18%, ADD 7.36%
- 2011-12 series, 2014-15 RE2: published nominal growth 10.6%, levels give RE2 10.30%, RE3 10.65%, ADD 10.68%
- 2011-12 series, 2014-15 RE3: published nominal growth 10.9%, levels give RE2 10.60%, RE3 10.96%, ADD 10.99%
- 2011-12 series, 2015-16 RE1: published nominal growth 9.9%, levels give AE1 8.07%, PE 9.04%, RE1 9.51%, RE2 9.99%, RE3 9.68%
- 2011-12 series, 2015-16 RE2: published real growth 8.1%, levels give AE1 6.84%, PE 6.97%, RE1 7.90%, RE2 8.21%, RE3 8.15%
- 2011-12 series, 2015-16 RE2: published nominal growth 10.3%, levels give AE1 8.77%, PE 9.75%, RE1 10.22%, RE2 10.70%, RE3 10.40%
- 2011-12 series, 2015-16 RE3: published real growth 7.9%, levels give AE1 6.69%, PE 6.82%, RE1 7.75%, RE2 8.05%, RE3 8.00%
- 2011-12 series, 2015-16 RE3: published nominal growth 10.4%, levels give AE1 8.84%, PE 9.81%, RE1 10.28%, RE2 10.76%, RE3 10.46%
- 2011-12 series, 2016-17 RE2: published real growth 8.1%, levels give AE1 8.35%, PE 8.35%, RE1 8.28%, RE2 8.01%, RE3 8.17%
- 2011-12 series, 2017-18 RE1: published nominal growth 11.2%, levels give AE1 12.52%, AE2 12.09%, PE 12.59%, RE1 12.07%, RE2 11.28%, RE3 11.07%
- 2011-12 series, 2017-18 RE3: published real growth 6.7%, levels give AE1 8.14%, AE2 8.05%, PE 7.83%, RE1 7.78%, RE2 6.88%, RE3 6.80%
- 2011-12 series, 2018-19 RE3: published real growth 6.4%, levels give AE1 7.76%, AE2 7.61%, PE 7.55%, RE1 6.17%, RE2 6.21%, RE3 6.45%
- 2011-12 series, 2019-20 RE3: published nominal growth 6.3%, levels give AE1 6.70%, AE2 5.51%, PE 5.75%, RE1 5.97%, RE2 6.44%, RE3 6.37%
- 2011-12 series, 2020-21 RE1: published real growth -6.5%, levels give AE1 -8.26%, AE2 -7.66%, PE -6.92%, RE1 -6.94%, RE2 -6.60%, RE3 -6.72%
- 2011-12 series, 2020-21 RE1: published nominal growth -1.3%, levels give AE1 -3.14%, AE2 -2.86%, PE -2.65%, RE1 -2.70%, RE2 -1.36%, RE3 -1.51%
- 2011-12 series, 2020-21 RE2: published nominal growth -1.3%, levels give AE1 -3.00%, AE2 -2.72%, PE -2.51%, RE1 -2.56%, RE2 -1.22%, RE3 -1.36%
- 2011-12 series, 2021-22 AE1: published real growth 9.1%, levels give AE1 9.78%, AE2 10.03%, PE 9.18%, RE1 8.81%, RE2 7.79%, RE3 7.73%
- 2011-12 series, 2021-22 AE1: published nominal growth 17.5%, levels give AE1 19.16%, AE2 18.53%, PE 17.57%, RE1 17.24%, RE2 17.07%, RE3 16.93%
- 2011-12 series, 2021-22 PE: published real growth 8.6%, levels give AE1 9.64%, AE2 9.89%, PE 9.05%, RE1 8.68%, RE2 7.66%, RE3 7.60%
- 2011-12 series, 2021-22 RE1: published nominal growth 18.3%, levels give AE1 20.48%, AE2 19.83%, PE 18.87%, RE1 18.53%, RE2 18.36%, RE3 18.22%
- 2011-12 series, 2021-22 RE2: published real growth 9.6%, levels give AE1 11.77%, AE2 12.03%, PE 11.17%, RE1 10.79%, RE2 9.75%, RE3 9.69%
- 2011-12 series, 2021-22 RE2: published nominal growth 18.8%, levels give AE1 21.12%, AE2 20.48%, PE 19.51%, RE1 19.17%, RE2 19.00%, RE3 18.85%
- 2011-12 series, 2022-23 AE1: published real growth 6.9%, levels give AE1 6.82%, AE2 6.69%, PE 6.95%, RE1 5.59%, RE2 4.92%
- 2011-12 series, 2022-23 AE1: published nominal growth 15.3%, levels give AE1 17.63%, AE2 15.50%, PE 15.39%, RE1 16.35%, RE2 15.72%
- 2011-12 series, 2022-23 PE: published nominal growth 16.0%, levels give AE1 17.34%, AE2 15.21%, PE 15.11%, RE1 16.06%, RE2 15.44%
- 2011-12 series, 2022-23 RE1: published real growth 6.9%, levels give AE1 8.93%, AE2 8.80%, PE 9.07%, RE1 7.68%, RE2 6.99%
- 2011-12 series, 2022-23 FINAL: published nominal growth 13.9%, levels give AE1 15.83%, AE2 13.73%, PE 13.63%, RE1 14.57%, RE2 13.96%
- 2011-12 series, 2023-24 AE1: published nominal growth 8.8%, levels give AE1 8.61%, AE2 9.02%, PE 8.87%, RE1 10.05%, FINAL 10.29%
- 2011-12 series, 2023-24 AE2: published real growth 7.5%, levels give AE1 9.71%, AE2 8.26%, PE 8.02%, RE1 7.58%, FINAL 6.96%
- 2011-12 series, 2023-24 AE2: published nominal growth 9.0%, levels give AE1 7.62%, AE2 8.04%, PE 7.89%, RE1 9.05%, FINAL 9.29%
- 2011-12 series, 2023-24 PE: published real growth 8.1%, levels give AE1 10.29%, AE2 8.83%, PE 8.59%, RE1 8.15%, FINAL 7.53%
- 2011-12 series, 2023-24 PE: published nominal growth 9.5%, levels give AE1 8.16%, AE2 8.57%, PE 8.42%, RE1 9.60%, FINAL 9.84%
- 2011-12 series, 2023-24 RE1: published real growth 9.1%, levels give AE1 11.99%, AE2 10.52%, PE 10.27%, RE1 9.83%, FINAL 9.19%
- 2011-12 series, 2024-25 AE1: published real growth 6.3%, levels give AE1 7.62%, AE2 6.93%, PE 6.37%, RE1 4.75%
- 2011-12 series, 2024-25 AE2: published real growth 6.4%, levels give AE1 9.41%, AE2 8.70%, PE 8.13%, RE1 6.48%
- 2011-12 series, 2024-25 AE2: published nominal growth 9.8%, levels give AE1 11.62%, AE2 12.64%, PE 12.08%, RE1 9.89%
- 2011-12 series, 2024-25 PE: published real growth 6.4%, levels give AE1 9.42%, AE2 8.71%, PE 8.14%, RE1 6.49%
- 2011-12 series, 2024-25 PE: published nominal growth 9.7%, levels give AE1 11.50%, AE2 12.52%, PE 11.96%, RE1 9.78%

## ✅ Quarters add up to the year; quarterly growth follows from levels
170 checks, 0 failures.

- 55 quarterly growth rates are within 1.5 points of the levels but not exact: MoSPI's API keeps only the latest quarterly levels, while each growth rate was announced against the year-earlier quarter as estimated at the time. Listed for review:
- 2011-12 series, 2012-13 Q1: published real growth 4.8%, levels give 4.87%
- 2011-12 series, 2012-13 Q1: published nominal growth 13.1%, levels give 13.20%
- 2011-12 series, 2012-13 Q2: published real growth 7.4%, levels give 7.49%
- 2011-12 series, 2012-13 Q3: published real growth 5.3%, levels give 5.38%
- 2011-12 series, 2012-13 Q4: published real growth 4.2%, levels give 4.30%
- 2011-12 series, 2012-13 Q4: published nominal growth 12.6%, levels give 12.69%
- 2011-12 series, 2013-14 Q2: published nominal growth 13.9%, levels give 13.97%
- 2011-12 series, 2014-15 Q2: published nominal growth 13.6%, levels give 13.69%
- 2011-12 series, 2014-15 Q4: published nominal growth 8.2%, levels give 8.29%
- 2011-12 series, 2015-16 Q1: published real growth 7.5%, levels give 7.59%
- 2011-12 series, 2015-16 Q1: published nominal growth 11.2%, levels give 11.29%
- 2011-12 series, 2015-16 Q2: published nominal growth 9.8%, levels give 9.89%
- 2011-12 series, 2015-16 Q3: published real growth 7.1%, levels give 7.20%
- 2011-12 series, 2015-16 Q3: published nominal growth 9.1%, levels give 9.16%
- 2011-12 series, 2015-16 Q4: published real growth 9.0%, levels give 9.09%
- 2011-12 series, 2015-16 Q4: published nominal growth 11.4%, levels give 11.50%
- 2011-12 series, 2016-17 Q1: published real growth 8.6%, levels give 8.68%
- 2011-12 series, 2016-17 Q2: published real growth 9.6%, levels give 9.67%
- 2011-12 series, 2016-17 Q2: published nominal growth 11.8%, levels give 11.87%
- 2011-12 series, 2016-17 Q3: published real growth 8.5%, levels give 8.58%
- 2011-12 series, 2016-17 Q3: published nominal growth 11.4%, levels give 11.46%
- 2011-12 series, 2016-17 Q4: published real growth 6.2%, levels give 6.29%
- 2011-12 series, 2016-17 Q4: published nominal growth 11.5%, levels give 11.55%
- 2011-12 series, 2017-18 Q3: published real growth 6.6%, levels give 6.67%
- 2011-12 series, 2017-18 Q3: published nominal growth 11.9%, levels give 11.98%
- 2011-12 series, 2018-19 Q1: published real growth 7.4%, levels give 7.50%
- 2011-12 series, 2018-19 Q1: published nominal growth 13.9%, levels give 13.98%
- 2011-12 series, 2018-19 Q2: published real growth 6.4%, levels give 6.46%
- 2011-12 series, 2018-19 Q2: published nominal growth 11.9%, levels give 12.00%
- 2011-12 series, 2019-20 Q1: published real growth 5.0%, levels give 5.10%
- 2011-12 series, 2019-20 Q1: published nominal growth 8.3%, levels give 8.36%
- 2011-12 series, 2019-20 Q2: published real growth 4.2%, levels give 4.30%
- 2011-12 series, 2019-20 Q2: published nominal growth 4.5%, levels give 4.56%
- 2011-12 series, 2019-20 Q3: published real growth 3.2%, levels give 3.26%
- 2011-12 series, 2019-20 Q3: published nominal growth 5.3%, levels give 5.38%
- 2011-12 series, 2020-21 Q1: published nominal growth -21.3%, levels give -21.36%
- 2011-12 series, 2020-21 Q2: published nominal growth -2.8%, levels give -2.87%
- 2011-12 series, 2020-21 Q3: published real growth 1.7%, levels give 1.78%
- 2011-12 series, 2020-21 Q3: published nominal growth 6.5%, levels give 6.60%
- 2011-12 series, 2020-21 Q4: published real growth 3.2%, levels give 3.29%
- 2011-12 series, 2021-22 Q1: published nominal growth 32.9%, levels give 32.98%
- 2011-12 series, 2021-22 Q2: published real growth 9.8%, levels give 9.87%
- 2011-12 series, 2021-22 Q4: published real growth 4.4%, levels give 4.45%
- 2011-12 series, 2022-23 Q1: published real growth 13.4%, levels give 13.49%
- 2011-12 series, 2022-23 Q2: published real growth 5.9%, levels give 5.96%
- 2011-12 series, 2022-23 Q2: published nominal growth 14.7%, levels give 14.76%
- 2011-12 series, 2022-23 Q4: published real growth 6.8%, levels give 6.90%
- 2011-12 series, 2023-24 Q1: published real growth 9.6%, levels give 9.66%
- 2011-12 series, 2023-24 Q4: published real growth 8.3%, levels give 8.35%
- 2011-12 series, 2024-25 Q1: published nominal growth 9.6%, levels give 9.65%
- 2011-12 series, 2024-25 Q2: published nominal growth 8.2%, levels give 8.28%
- 2011-12 series, 2024-25 Q3: published real growth 6.3%, levels give 6.37%
- 2011-12 series, 2024-25 Q3: published nominal growth 10.2%, levels give 10.28%
- 2011-12 series, 2024-25 Q4: published real growth 7.3%, levels give 7.38%
- 2011-12 series, 2024-25 Q4: published nominal growth 10.7%, levels give 10.76%

## ✅ Back series joins the current series
3 checks, 0 failures.

- 2011-12 GDP (cur): back series 8,736,331, current series ADD 8,736,328
- 2011-12 GDP (con): back series 8,736,331, current series ADD 8,736,328
- Long-run series runs 1950-51 to 2025-26 without gaps.

## ✅ Budget GDP assumption found and consistent
24 checks, 0 failures.

- Budget 2018-19: ₹18,722,302 crore is 11.54% over ₹16,784,679 crore; printed 11.5%
- Budget 2019-20: ₹21,100,607 crore is 11.99% over ₹18,840,731 crore; printed 12.0%
- Budget 2020-21: ₹22,489,420 crore is 10.01% over ₹20,442,233 crore; printed 10.0%
- Budget 2021-22: ₹22,287,379 crore is 14.40% over ₹19,481,975 crore; printed 14.4%
- Budget 2022-23: ₹25,800,000 crore is 11.14% over ₹23,214,703 crore; printed 11.1%
- Budget 2023-24: ₹30,175,065 crore is 10.50% over ₹27,307,751 crore; printed 10.5%
- Budget 2024-25: ₹32,636,912 crore is 10.50% over ₹29,535,667 crore; printed 10.5%
- Budget 2025-26: ₹35,697,923 crore is 10.14% over ₹32,411,406 crore; printed 10.1%
- Budget 2025-26: The two rupee amounts are not in the PDF's text layer; they were read from the rendered page.

## ✅ Every forecast is quoted from its official document
224 checks, 0 failures.

- Economic Survey (Ministry of Finance), Economic Survey 2013-14 → 2014-15: quote found with other text (a margin box or second column) printed between its words
- 114 quoted sentences found in their official documents; recorded numbers checked against each sentence.

## ✅ Spending side: size of the statistical discrepancy (for review, not failures)
83 checks, 0 failures.

- GDP is measured from production; the spending components are estimated separately, and MoSPI shows the difference as 'discrepancies'. Gaps above 3% of GDP:
- 2011-12-back series, 1999-2000 BACK: discrepancy -5.2% of GDP (current prices)
- 2011-12-back series, 2001-02 BACK: discrepancy -4.9% of GDP (current prices)
- 2011-12-back series, 2002-03 BACK: discrepancy -3.6% of GDP (current prices)
- 2011-12-back series, 2007-08 BACK: discrepancy -3.5% of GDP (current prices)

## ✅ Large revisions to growth (for review, not failures)
0 checks, 0 failures.

- 2016-17: real growth first 7.1% (AE1), latest 8.3% (RE3), revised +1.2 points
- 2019-20: real growth first 5.0% (AE1), latest 3.8% (RE3), revised -1.2 points
- 2020-21: real growth first -7.7% (AE1), latest -5.7% (RE3), revised +2.0 points
- 2023-24: real growth first 7.3% (AE1), latest 9.1% (RE1), revised +1.8 points